This is the sort of thing that really only comes through experience. Like you say, just too many bottles out there to ever compile a guide, and the prices fluctuate wildly at auctions. A $50 bottle on Wednesday might be a $200 bottle on Friday, just depending on who happens to be looking at...
That's really cool! I found this image of bottles from the other Pop Shoppe, and they used both of those designs. I wonder if these wooden models originated with them - did you get them from the same place? I don't remember seeing anyone else using that diamond design before. I know...
Welcome to the forum! I suspect the blue one is even newer, when did cobalt blue wine bottles first show up, the 80s or so? I associate them with the 21st century for the most part. The one on the left looks older, maybe 1930s or so? And the one on the right is hard to date, probably...
I haven't been able to find any examples of that one online either, which is a bit surprising because it looks like this company's bottles are pretty well-documented. It's got a vague resemblance to the Shalamar bottles, so maybe some variation on that product? Age-wise I suspect it's not that...
Looks like yours is one of the early (though not quite earliest) Canadian ones. Strange that they were asking $30-50 for the other ones, not many Orange Crushes are worth that and it looks like you got one of the better ones anyway. I assume it must be one of those antique stores which sell...
I was so certain that the dog was a pipe holder, but apparently it's actually a letter holder. It used to have a metal spring fitted into that slot on the back which you could put letters in:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/235436004832
Wow, that is incredible! I was imagining it was going to be a rusty and corroded sword you found metal detecting or something, but that thing is stunning, and in fantastic condition! That's a curb find of a lifetime!
That's so cool! I bet there's a lot more buried in the mud there. Have you tried looking for historic aerial photos to see if you can see the wrecked boat? It would likely have been visible there for a while, and there's a good chance it would have been intact within the past 100 years. That...
My guess is that it's European. It seems a bit too plain of a design to be a modern reproduction. Definitely doesn't look like old American glass to me but doesn't strike me as a repro either.
That's interesting about the Hawaii ones! The ones we get like this are usually because inexperienced mold-cutters got confused about having to write backwards/mirrored when doing the molds, which was probably the case here. You also see misspellings of people and towns with less common names...