Now that is help. I was wondering what the JC was. Thought it might be a Holy Roller beer. No, seriously should I be looking for Knight and McDonough or First and Henderson? This is a photo of the other side of the bottle.
I have a bottle. It is a BIM with blob top. On the front is has 1876 KNIGHT & McDONOUGH around FIRST AND HENDERSON J.C. on the back it has in large block letters K McD on the bottom it has NEVER SOLD. it is about the size of a beer bottle. I am guessing that it may have been thrown overboard...