The top certainly looks different than the one listed on sodasandbeers.com
http://www.sodasandbeers.com/SABShowBottle.aspx?Bottle=53626AA&Firm_Number=53626
Sheared top. Smooth base.
"WITH MALICE TOWARDS NONE" around Lincoln's portrait.
"WITH CHARITY TOWARDS ALL"around log cabin on back.
No other identifying marks.
Any guesses at value?