FlouiseA27
Member
Hey Everyone!
I just joined this forum... and I'm so happy I found it!
My question is about bottle books; price guides, identifications, history, etc.
The only book I have right now is by Michael Polak and is called "Bottles Identification and Price Guide", and it is the 4th edition.
Over the past 4 years that I have been collecting antique bottles and using this book, I have become increasingly disappointed with it. I know it is impossible to list all the bottles ever made (wouldn't that be something?!), or even all the bottles in the U.S., however I feel like this book is missing alot of popular and noteworthy bottles. I have also noticed many gramatical and punctuation errors that make me question Polak's reputability.
As I've been searching the internet to purchase a new and possibly more extensive bottle book and/or price guide, Polak's name comes up often. It makes me think: "If he's written so many books, then he must be extrememly knowledgeable about this topic and trustworthy.", but it also makes me think: "If he's written so many books, shouldn't he have it right by now?".
Does anyone else feel this way about Polak? Maybe it's just that one book I have. Maybe I'm being demanding and unrealistic. Maybe there is a better book of prices and identifications that someone recommends? Not jars, not jugs, not Avon bottles... just bottles - I would love that!
Thank you for any and all information, opinions, and recommendations you can give me... remember; no reply post is too small!
I just joined this forum... and I'm so happy I found it!
My question is about bottle books; price guides, identifications, history, etc.
The only book I have right now is by Michael Polak and is called "Bottles Identification and Price Guide", and it is the 4th edition.
Over the past 4 years that I have been collecting antique bottles and using this book, I have become increasingly disappointed with it. I know it is impossible to list all the bottles ever made (wouldn't that be something?!), or even all the bottles in the U.S., however I feel like this book is missing alot of popular and noteworthy bottles. I have also noticed many gramatical and punctuation errors that make me question Polak's reputability.
As I've been searching the internet to purchase a new and possibly more extensive bottle book and/or price guide, Polak's name comes up often. It makes me think: "If he's written so many books, then he must be extrememly knowledgeable about this topic and trustworthy.", but it also makes me think: "If he's written so many books, shouldn't he have it right by now?".
Does anyone else feel this way about Polak? Maybe it's just that one book I have. Maybe I'm being demanding and unrealistic. Maybe there is a better book of prices and identifications that someone recommends? Not jars, not jugs, not Avon bottles... just bottles - I would love that!
Thank you for any and all information, opinions, and recommendations you can give me... remember; no reply post is too small!