Hi justglass, I just looked at the three on eBay and the one you just pictured there seemed to be the best of the three listed. and the cheapest. There were at least four different lettering layouts for the Hotchkiss' bottles. I like the one on eBay with the bubble in the neck the best. It also has sloppy glass under the finish.
I think from the bubbles or wood particles in the glass also says it was Mountain Glass, though i didn't realize they made that color at that plant. To bad I am so broke. RED Matthews
All botttles mentioned in your post are just different variants, what makes the bottles worth more is the 3 Cs. Condition, Crudity and mostly Color. Randy