I agree they both look fine to me. Many companies used milk glass bottles for various products. Sanitol for the teeth comes in a milkglass bottle with a stopper, and Armour an co. used a variety of milkglass bottles around 1900 -1910 for all kinds of meat juice and potted meat products. Hope you have as much fun as I did digging and collecting. It was 5 years after I started before I decided which category of bottle I wanted to collect, ( it was Chicago sodas). Have you found any one category more appealing yet? Wishing you the very best in collecting.