First of all, pontil marks occur on the base of bottles and not on the tops. I have a listing of it but it comes with a smooth base. If it is actually pontiled, it would be a very rare bottle. Is their any way you could post a picture of the base? Here is the information of the different embossings of the bottle I found:
Joly, Charles
51014AA Embossed: (1) CHAS JOLY / NO 9 / SO SEVENTH ST / (2) PHILADELPHIA // THIS BOTTLE / NOT TO / BE SOLD //
Bottle: Glass, Champaign Beer, 2 leaf, 9 1/2 x 2 7/16 (5)
1. Yellowish Green, Smooth Base, Rounded Taper, Metal Lightning Stopper, Hand Blown
2. Aqua, Smooth Base, Rounded Taper, Cork Stopper, Hand Blown
51014AB Embossed: // s // CHAs JOLY // PHILA //
Bottle: Glass, Export Ale, 3 leaf, 9 1/4 x ?
Notes: The "s" in "CHAs" is raised and underlined.
1. Amber, Smooth Base, Double Tapered Collar, Cork Stopper, Hand Blown, Circ: 1878-85
51014AJ Embossed: (1) JOLY. / PHILADELPHIA. / PA. // c // // b // MADE BY JOHN MATTHEWS NY PAT JUNE 11 1872
Bottle: Glass, Champaign Beer, 2 leaf, 9 1/4 x 2 13/16 (4 1/2)
Notes: Has bulb in neck below lip.
1. Aqua, Smooth Base, Tapered Collar, Matthews Twist on Stopper, Hand Blown
sorry i thought a pontil was when the top has aroundish top. Bottle has smooth base. My Email Is Cebuls8@aol.com Email me& ill send pics. I plan on listing thisonebayso please give me all info as possiable.
I have about the same as Bottleman except it is
CHARLES JOLY(in circle)
PHILADELPHIA JAMICA
SARSAPARILLA
1848 city director shows start of establishment
Aqua 10" x 2 1/2" DIAMETER