Sounds like this continues to be an awesome dig! The rarity system on Hutchbook is a bit tricky; Ron gets feedback from local collectors on how rare they think it is, but in many cases that rarity rating may not be valid. I wouldn't stake a lot on those ratings; there are "rare" hutch sodas on there that I have personally handled dozens of. Obviously, with many small town hutch sodas being quite scarce, digging 20 of the same hutch soda will definitely also change the rarity rating.