Is this a pontil?

[butchndad]

pontil or just a lookalike
Thanks


“Is it the good title soup or merely the mock?”

 

[bottles_inc]

Don't think so

 

[Harry Pristis]

Maybe. If this is a pontil scar, it is remarkably focused on the valley surrounding the mammelon. It's almost too much scarring and too regular.

 

[butchndad]

Maybe. If this is a pontil scar, it is remarkably focused on the valley surrounding the mammelon. It's almost too much scarring and too regular.

a follow up question (and my apologies if it's a stupid question): is this lip an applied square ring lip? and is the lip consistent with, or overlap with the time period of pontils? Trying to learn. Thank you.

 

[Harry Pristis]

You'll have to provide a close-up of the lip.

 

[butchndad]

You'll have to provide a close-up of the lip.

View attachment 224767

Hopefully good enough views from top and side. Thanks again

 

[butchndad]

Hopefully good enough views from top and side. Thanks again