Thanks for the information! I came across that site while searching - sent an email to "Jee Pee", but got no response.
The shape of the bottle is what throws me off. Nothing embossed on it either. Interestingly, the bottle was found alongside a mint John Lasser bottle (Chicago bottling...
I found this bottle upon moving into a house in Chicago about 13 years ago. It was in the basement with a couple other old bottles. I recently tried to find information on it, but I can't find anything resembling the type of bottle with the Belle of Lincoln label. The bottle is unmarked, but...