Thanks Jim! I've been keeping a check on Craigslist as well as Etsy. I saw that bottle on Ebay a few days ago and thought that that was it, but the one I'm looking for doesn't have the pattern on the bottom.
Thanks for all of your help!
I am looking for a particular Pine Hill, NY 5 gallon water bottle. It is aqua glass and the wording on the bottle that I am looking for includes: Pine Hill Crystal Spring Water Co, Catskill, NY.
In addition to the asking price, a picture of what you might have available would be great. This...