I've become quite picky and am short on room..I'd still keep it. I just traded some nice bottles for cracked Milk (big nasty crack) but it was a super rare one from long gone non existent ghost town. Sorta, town still there, just changed there name way back in 1917. I dug a huge Milk bottle dump once, 100's of them, but every one damaged, from minor damage, lip chips to more severe damage, like small holes & bigger holes ect, ect. I kept a few with minor damage. LEON.