No damage other than minor surface scratches, all are open pontiled. The mallet has 25% surface oxidation showing a refired pontil. I purchased these from a doctor's estate and I believe these are from the fleet of galleons that sunk off the East coast of Florida in 1715. I can not however warrant that supposition. These are not reproductions. You name a price you'll pay for one of them and if I think it's fair we'll go from there. The bulbous bottle on top of the book case is not in the picture of those on my desk...the other two on top are.