Thanks very much for the comments. The only thing that I remember about the label (about half of which was on the bottle, and it was fairly torn) was that it was in black and white with a fair amount of writing on it. I would put the construction of the house as mid-1850's so I think the bottle...
In the mid 70's, I spent the summer in a house on Orange Street on Nantucket. I found this bottle in the attic. It's made of dark green glass and, at the time, had a somewhat soiled label on it. Sadly, I promptly washed it off then, and can't remember what it said. The bottle seems to have a...