What is this? Is it old? Found in a Minnesota lake, it is brown-glazed ceramic, with no glazing on the bottom, and a hole in the top, big enough for me to stick my index finger in. If it was an ashtray, it'd have to be disposable, because there would be no way to get the butts out. If it was a penholder, it could only hold one. The inside portion I can see is also glazed. The area had residential & hotel garbage dumped there from the later 1800s through about the 1930s...