Brown Stubby Beverages - Worth the ask price?

[JKL]

I had a fellow collector ask if I was interested in a brown 12 oz Stubby Beverage. Bottle is mint and he is asking $35.
I hesitated at that price. Is it worth it?
Pic is not the exact bottle.
He also has a Sunnyside ACL from Toronto and a Vitality from Petawawa Ont he wants $20 each for. Those are too much $$
Any info you Canadian collectors can offer is helpful.

 

[SODABOB]

I'm not a Canadian collector and don't know the value - but I do know that private seller's and eBay aren't the only games in town


Etsy $19.58 + $15.0 = $34.58

Webb's Stubby Bottle Pop Soda Amber Glass Beverages Cola | Etsy

Kijiji

Five bottles for the price of one ???

$15. - Availability/Shipping ???

Vintage 5 Soda Pop Bottles ! | Arts & Collectibles | Mississauga / Peel Region | Kijiji

 

[JKL]

@SODABOB I appreciate the feedback.
I saw the Kijiji ad and that seller is about an hour's drive for me.
Thanks for the Etsy info. I find Ebay to be a good resource but shipping costs typically make the investment to much $$ for what I want to spend.
I hate to pass up a bottle in such great condition but I hate to overpay even more!

 

[Canadacan]

It all depends on condition, at that price I'd wan a mint example. My 12oz has a lil bit of case wear and some fade to the label but still displays great1...for $5 bucks I'm not complaining.

 

[Donas12]

The 12 oz is a little tougher to find than the more common 10 oz. It’s hard finding mint examples with no case wear. I thinks it’s a $20-25 bottle with no case wear or acl fade.

 

[JKL]

The 12 oz is a little tougher to find than the more common 10 oz. It’s hard finding mint examples with no case wear. I thinks it’s a $20-25 bottle with no case wear or acl fade.

Thanks for your reply. I passed on that bottle.

 

[RCO]

what vitality does he want $20 for , I have a couple that I paid maybe $5 or $10 for , it was a long lasting bottler so they have a few different sizes and bottles out there . I don't imagine many people would pay $20 for a common vitality though

 

[JKL]

what vitality does he want $20 for , I have a couple that I paid maybe $5 or $10 for , it was a long lasting bottler so they have a few different sizes and bottles out there . I don't imagine many people would pay $20 for a common vitality though

The Vitality bottle is one I already had. The one I have I paid $2 for. $20 was very high.

 

[RCO]

that's like the most common vitality bottle , is a couple others that are harder to find , such as smaller 7 oz and bigger 30 oz versions . which come in clear and green bottles

$20 for that one is crazy even in good condition , someone is walking around antique malls and seeing high prices and assuming people will actually pay it , which is unlikely