My first Peoria, IL Iron Pontiled Soda! (and other bottle show finds)

Welcome to our Antique Bottle community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Plumbata

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 4, 2007
Messages
2,732
Reaction score
47
Points
48
Location
Peoria Co.
September 11th was a very good day here in central Illinois. The local bottle show once again made its annual appearance and my father and I were on the road early to make sure that we got there before all the good stuff got gobbled up.

I walked through the rows briskly, but was impeded by several of the dealers who haven't seen me in a while and wanted to catch-up. Thankfully it didn't stop me from snapping up the absolute best blown Peoria bottle in the entire show! (a good collector/dealer friend had a 400+ local ACL, but I'm not really into those)

I couldn't believe my good fortune when I made it to the last row and saw this bottle sitting on the table of a 40+ year collector and club member, with what I considered a very reasonable price tag of 150.00. After bringing my father over to scrutinize the bottle with me, I decided that it had to become part of the collection.

"R. Hickey Peoria ILLS"

313655_10100858935847490_1937295_66471680_587002465_n.jpg


I told the dealer that I wanted to buy it, and he said that I could have it for 125.00! [:)][:)][:)] I didn't try to bring him down or anything, but perhaps he remembers when I was a prepubescent kid drooling over the bottles at the club back in the 90s, and wanted to help out my collection. Really nice thing he did for me.

Now correct me if I am wrong, but being 1 of the 3 IP bottles known from Peoria, even if the most prevalent one, makes it somewhat desirable as far as pontiled sodas go. I'd take it over 10 Philly IPs anyday! I can't imagine that I could have gotten it for less than at least double what i was charged if it showed up in eBay, but I have no actual experience regarding this bottle's market value (aside from the 150 I was willing to pay).

More shots:
313082_10100858936111960_1937295_66471683_1761444743_n.jpg

310584_10100858936271640_1937295_66471684_1428955380_n.jpg


And next to a smooth-base R. Hickey in considerably worse shape and with some darn weak embossing:

309884_10100858935508170_1937295_66471678_2099645548_n.jpg


In addition to the Peoria Pontil, I got a beat and sickly tooled-top Seitz (perhaps one cast-away by rick and his crew? [:D]) for a buck and the "Umatilla Indian Relief" from Detroit with a few flakes off the top for 5.

300923_10100858936436310_1937295_66471685_129298600_n.jpg


A pretty good day I'd say! [:)]

I've been digging a decent bit too, just haven't posted anything lately. Take care and thanks for lookin' folks. [:)]
 

RIBottleguy

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2008
Messages
2,320
Reaction score
192
Points
63
Location
Providence, RI
Congrats on that fine acquisition! There are less than ten RI sodas with iron pontils, and only one that goes for under $100, none of them are mine yet. Oh, and don't forget the one OP one that sells for $6,000+
 

epackage

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 3, 2009
Messages
19,057
Reaction score
425
Points
83
Location
Jersey
This is a beauty Plumb, strong embossing for sure....Jim




9D054A21B4E04AD08A8626BFB1E08B43.jpg
 

Attachments

  • 9D054A21B4E04AD08A8626BFB1E08B43.jpg
    9D054A21B4E04AD08A8626BFB1E08B43.jpg
    40.8 KB · Views: 95

blobbottlebob

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 20, 2005
Messages
4,789
Reaction score
12
Points
36
Location
Wisconsin
Plumb. That is flat out amazing. In my humble opinion, that bottle is way way better. Sure, for a smooth based example, I'd say that it might be about right - but graphite pontilled - you did really well. Those things never get newer. And even if it is common (which I doubt) every collector will pay for early pontilled stuff. Nice purchase!
 

Jim

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2005
Messages
3,745
Reaction score
10
Points
0
Location
Lewistown, PA
Sweeeeet! Nothing beats a local pontiled soda. I love the font style on early Midwestern sodas like that one.

Based on my experience with rare, local iron pontil sodas, I would deduce that you got a helluva deal. The last two from my collecting area were an aqua one from Huntingdon, PA that went for $860, and an emerald green one from Lewistown that brought $770. I bought the Lewistown one, and was happy to get it for that. Now, we Central PA collectors are a bit insane, but that's cool.

Any pontil soda that is at least uncommon and not from a huge city is a deal at $125. They're just not getting any easier to find. That bottle found a good home with a guy who will truly appreciate it. ~Jim
 

DruggistBottles

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 2, 2009
Messages
397
Reaction score
1
Points
0
Location
Belleville ILL (St. Louis Area)
Very nice bottle indeed. Good luck getting the others! I use to have a smooth based J. B. St. Clair from Peoria. That was from a fun dig I did up there way back. Unfortunately the land owner changed their mind when they saw the huge mound of excavated dirt. We were just getting into the pontils. And had several feet to go. The last bottle out was a pontiled barrel. Man were we pissed. Some day I will go back…
 

Staff online

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
83,417
Messages
744,289
Members
24,467
Latest member
tasha85
Top