Here's another pontil puzzle. Now they were using iron pontils on barrel bitters into the 1870's! At least he calls it an iron pontil instead of graphite. I will give him that. Seems like a novice and not really a bottle guy. Probably did a tad of research and/or was told that by the person he got it from. Probably picked it up cheap in a shop maybe because it's got burst bubbles and the lip is chunked(darn near destroyed) and its unembossed.. Seems like a decent seller who just picked up a few bottles somewhere but it's funny how misinformation is so widely propagated on Ebay. This guy just tried to list and be as accurate as possible with his information at hand. Nothing against him.